Sustainably unpersuaded: how persuasion narrows our vision of sustainability

ABSTRACT

In this paper we provide a critical analysis of persuasive sustainability research from 2009-2011. Drawing on critical sociological theory of modernism, we argue that persuasion is based on a limited framing of sustainability, human behavior, and their interrelationship. This makes supporting sustainability easier, but leads to characteristic patterns of breakdown. We then detail problems that emerge from this narrowing of vision, such as how the framing of sustainability as the optimization of a simple metrics places technologies incorrectly as objective arbiters over complex issues of sustainability. We conclude by suggesting alternative approaches to move beyond these problems.

References

1. Amsel, N., and Tomlinson, B. 2010. Green tracker: a tool for estimating the energy consumption of software. Proc CHI EA '10. ACM, 3337--3342.
2. Aoki, P. M., Honicky, R. J., Mainwaring, A., Myers, C., Paulos, E., Subramanian, S., and Woodruff, A. 2009. A vehicle for research: using street sweepers to explore the landscape of environmental community action. Proc CHI '09. ACM, 375--384.
3. Baumer, E. P. S., Katz, S. J., Freeman, J. E., Adams, P., Gonzales, A. L., Pollak, J. P., Retelny, D., Niederdeppe, J., Olson, C., and Gay, G. 2012. Prescriptive persuasion and open-ended social awareness: Expanding the design space of mobile health. Proc. CSCW '12. ACM.
4. Bogost, I. Persuasive Games. MIT Press. 2007.
5. Broms, L., Katzeff, C., Bång, M., Nyblom, Å., Ilstedt Hjelm, S., and Ehrnberger, K. 2010. Coffee maker patterns and the design of energy feedback artefacts. Proc DIS '10. ACM, 93--102.
6. Buchanan, R. 1985. Declaration by design: Rhetoric, argument, and demonstration in design practice. Design Issues, 2(1):4--22.
7. Chetty, M., Bernheim Brush, A. J., Meyers, B. R., and Johns, P. 2009. It's not easy being green: understanding home computer power management. Proc CHI '09. ACM, 1033--1042.
8. Davis, J. 2009. Design methods for ethical persuasive computing. Proc Persuasive '09. ACM, Article 6, 8 pages.
9. Dillahunt, T., Mankoff, J., Paulos, E., and Fussell, S. 2009. It's not all about "Green": energy use in lowincome communities. Proc Ubicomp '09. ACM, 255--264.
10. Dillahunt, T., Mankoff, J., and Paulos, E. 2010. Understanding conflict between landlords and tenants: implications for energy sensing and feedback. Proc Ubicomp '10. ACM, 149--158.
11. DiSalvo, C., Sengers, P., and Brynjarsdóttir, H. 2010. Mapping the landscape of sustainable HCI. Proc CHI '10. ACM, 1975--1984.
12. DiSalvo, C., Louw, M., Coupland, J., and Steiner, M. 2009. Local issues, local uses. Proc. Creativity & Cognition '09. ACM: 245--254.
13. Dourish, P. 2010. HCI and environmental sustainability: The politics of design and the design of politics. Proc DIS '10. ACM, 1--10.
14. Edwards, P. 1996. The closed world: Computers and the politics of discourse in Cold War America. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
15. Ferris, B., Watkins, K., and Borning, A. 2010. OneBusAway: results from providing real-time arrival information for public transit. Proc CHI '10. ACM, 1807--1816.
16. Fogg, B. J. 1998. Persuasive computers: perspectives and research directions. Proc CHI '98, ACM, 225--232.
17. Fogg, B. J. 2003. Persuasive technology: Using computers to change what we think and do. Morgan Kaufmann Publishers, 2003.
18. Foster, D., Blythe, M., Cairns, P., and Lawson, S. 2010. Competitive carbon counting: can social networking sites make saving energy more enjoyable? Proc CHI EA '10. ACM, 4039--4044.
19. Foster, D., Linehan, C., Lawson, S., and Kirman, B. 2011. Power ballads: deploying aversive energy feedback in social media. Proc CHI EA '11. ACM, 2221--2226.
20. Froehlich, J., Dillahunt, T., Klasnja, P., Mankoff, J., Consolvo, S., Harrison, B., and Landay, J. A. 2009. UbiGreen: investigating a mobile tool for tracking and supporting green transportation habits. Proc CHI '09. ACM, 1043--1052.
21. Froehlich, J., Findlater, L., and Landay, J. 2010. The design of eco-feedback technology. Proc CHI '10. ACM, 1999--2008.
22. Gartland, A. A., and Piasek, P. 2009. Weigh your waste: a sustainable way to reduce waste. Proc CHI EA '09. ACM, 2853--2858.
23. Gustafsson, A., Bång, M., and Svahn, M. 2009. Power explorer: a casual game style for encouraging long term behavior change among teenagers. Proc ACE '09. ACM, 182--189.
24. Gaver, W., Jacob Beaver and S. Benford. 2003. Ambiguity as a Resource for Design. Proc CHI '09. ACM, 233--240.
25. Ham, J., Midden, C., and Beute, F. 2009. Can ambient persuasive technology persuade unconsciously?: Using subliminal feedback to influence energy consumption ratings of household appliances. Proc Persuasive '09. ACM, Article 29, 6 pages.
26. He, H. A., Greenberg, S., and Huang, E. M. 2010. One size does not fit all: applying the transtheoretical model to energy feedback technology design. Proc CHI '10. ACM, 927--936.
27. Hirsch, T., and Anderson, K. 2010. Cross currents: water scarcity and sustainable CHI. Proc CHI EA '10. ACM, 2843--2852.
28. Hirsch, T., Sengers, P., Blevis, E., Beckwith, R., and Parikh, T. 2010. Making food, producing sustainability. Proc CHI EA '10. ACM, 3147--3150.
29. Jackson, T. 2005. Motivating sustainable consumption: a review of evidence on consumer behavior and behavioral change. Sustainable Development Research Network. Policy Studies Institute, London.
30. Jönsson, L., Broms, L., and Katzeff, C. 2010. Watt-Lite: energy statistics made tangible. Proc DIS '10. ACM, 240--243.
31. Kappel, K., and Grechenig, T. 2009. "show-me": water consumption at a glance to promote water conservation in the shower. Proc Persuasive '09. ACM, Article 26, 6 pages.
32. Kim, S., and Paulos, E. 2010. InAir: sharing indoor air quality measurements and visualizations. Proc CHI '10. ACM, 1861--1870.
33. Kim, T., Hong, H., and Magerko, B. 2009. Coralog: use-aware visualization connecting human micro-activities to environmental change. Proc CHI EA '09. ACM, 4303--4308.
34. Kim, T., Hong, H., and Magerko, B. 2010. Design requirements for ambient display that supports sustainable lifestyle. Proc DIS '10. ACM, 103--112.
35. Kuijer, L., and Jong, A. de. 2011. Exploring Practices of Thermal Comfort for Sustainable Design. Everyday Practice and Sustainable HCI, Workshop at CHI Conf. Vancouver, BC.
36. Kuznetsov, S. and Paulos, E. 2010. Upstream: motivating water conservation with low-cost water flow sensing and persuasive displays. Proc CHI '10. ACM, 1851--1860.
37. Kuznetsov, S. and Paulos, E. 2010. Participatory sensing in public spaces: activating urban surfaces with sensor probes. Proc DIS '10. ACM, 21--30.
38. Laschke, M., Hassenzahl, M., Diefenbach, S., and Tippkämper, M. 2011. With a little help from a friend: a shower calendar to save water. Proc CHI EA '11. ACM, 633--646.
39. Lee, H., Lee, W., and Lim, Y.-K. 2010. The effect of eco-driving system towards sustainable driving behavior. Proc CHI EA '10. ACM, 4255--4260.
40. Lehrer, D., and Vasudev, J. 2011. Evaluating a social media application for sustainability in the workplace. Proc CHI EA '11. ACM, 2161--2166.
41. Miller, T. M., Rich, P., and Davis, J. 2009. ADAPT: audience design of ambient persuasive technology. Proc CHI EA '09. ACM, 4165--4170.
42. Odom, W. 2010. "Mate, we don't need a chip to tell us the soil's dry": Opportunities for designing interactive systems to support urban food production. Proc DIS '10. ACM, 232--235.
43. Petersen, D., Steele, J., and Wilkerson, J. 2009. WattBot: A residential electricity monitoring and feedback system. Proc CHI EA '09. ACM, 2847--2852.
44. Pierce, J., Fan, C., Lomas, D., Marcu, G., and Paulos, E. 2010. Some consideration on the (in)effectiveness of residential energy feedback systems. Proc DIS '10. ACM, 244--247.
45. Pierce, J., and Paulos, E. 2010. Materializing energy. Proc DIS '10. ACM, 113--122.
46. Pierce, J., Schiano, D. J., and Paulos, E. 2010. Home, habits, and energy: examining domestic interactions and energy consumption. Proc CHI '10. ACM, 1985--1994.
47. Purpura, S., Schwanda, V., Williams, K., Stubler, W., and Sengers, P. 2011. Fit4life: the design of a persuasive technology promoting healthy behavior and ideal weight. Proc CHI '11. ACM, 423--432.
48. Ritzer, G. 1993. The McDonaldization of American society: An investigation into the changing character of contemporary social life. Newbury Park, CA: Pine Forge Press.
49. Scott, J. C. 1999. Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. Yale University Press.
50. Sengers, P., Boehner, K., David, S. and Kaye. J. 2005. Reflective Design. Proc. Critical Computing '05. ACM, 49--58.
51. Shiraishi, M., Washio, Y., Takayama, C., Lehdonvirta, V., Kimura, H., and Nakajima, T. 2009. Using individual, social and economic persuasion techniques to reduce CO2 emissions in a family setting. Proc Persuasive '09. ACM, Article 13, 8 pages.
52. Shrubsole, P., Lavrysen, T., Janse, M., and Weda, H. 2011. Flo: raising family awareness about electricity use. Proc CHI EA '11. ACM, 669--672.
53. Sohn, M., Nam, T., and Lee, W. 2009. Designing with unconscious human behaviors for eco-friendly interaction. Proc CHI EA '09. ACM, 2651--2654.
54. Strengers, Y. 2008. Smart metering demand management programs: challenging the comfort and cleanliness habitus of households. Proc OZCHI '08. ACM, 9--16.
55. Strengers. Y. A. A. 2011. Designing eco-feedback systems for everyday life. Proc CHI '11. ACM, 2135--2144.
56. Suchman, L. 2002. Located Accountabilities in Technology Production. Scand. J. Inf. Syst. 14, 2, 91--105.
57. Weber, M. 2002. Baehr, P. R., and Wells, G. C., ed., trans., The Protestant ethic and the "spirit" of capitalism and other writings. Penguin.
58. Woodruff, A., Hasbrouck, J., and Augustin, S. 2008. A bright green perspective on sustainable choices. Proc CHI '08. ACM, 313--322.
59. Xiao, J. and Fan, J. 2009. PrintMarmoset: Redesigning the print button for sustainability. Proc. CHI '09. ACM, New York, 109--112.
60. Zapico, J. L., Turpeinen, M., and Brandt, N. 2009. Climate persuasive services: changing behavior towards low-carbon lifestyles. Proc Persuasive '09. ACM, Article 14, 8 pages.

Index Terms

• Human-centered computing