Do Health Information Exchanges Deter Repetition of Medical Services?

Abstract

Repetition of medical services by providers is one of the major sources of healthcare costs. The lack of access to previous medical information on a patient at the point of care often leads a physician to perform medical procedures that have already been done. Multiple healthcare initiatives and legislation at both the federal and state levels have mandated Health Information Exchange (HIE) systems to address this problem. This study aims to assess the extent to which HIE could reduce these repetitions, using data from Centers for Medicare 8 Medicaid Services and a regional HIE organization. A 2-Stage Least Square model is developed to predict the impact of HIE on repetitions of two classes of procedures: diagnostic and therapeutic. The first stage is a predictive analytic model that estimates the duration of tenure of each HIE member-practice. Based on these estimates, the second stage predicts the effect of providers’ HIE tenure on their repetition of medical services. The model incorporates moderating effects of a federal quality assurance program and the complexity of medical procedures with a set of control variables. Our analyses show that a practice's tenure with HIE significantly lowers the repetition of therapeutic medical procedures, while diagnostic procedures are not impacted. The medical reasons for the effects observed in each class of procedures are discussed. The results will inform healthcare policymakers and provide insights on the business models of HIE platforms.

References

1. Allison, P. When Can You Safely Ignore Multicollinearity? 2012. Retrieved from http://statisticalhorizons.com/multicollinearity.
2. AMA. 2015. Physician Quality Reporting System. Retrieved February 2016 From http://www.ama-assn.org/ama/pub/physician-resources/clinical-practice-improvement/clinical-quality/physician-quality-reporting-system.page.
3. J. Angrist and A. B. Krueger. 2001. Instrumental variables and the search for identification: From supply and demand to natural experiments. National Bureau of Economic Research 25 (2001), 69--85.
4. R. Aron, S. Dutta, R. Janakiraman, and P. A. Pathak. 2011. The impact of automation of systems on medical errors: Evidence from field research. Inform. Syst. Res. 22, 3 (2011), 429--446.
5. A. S. Ash, M. A. Posner, J. Speckman, S. Franco, A. C. Yacht, and L. Bramwell. 2003. Using claims data to examine mortality trends following hospitalization for heart attack in Medicare. Health Serv. Res. 38, 5 (2003), 1253--1262.
6. A. M. Audet, M. M. Doty, J. Peugh, J. Shamasdin, K. Zapert, and S. Schoenbaum. 2004. Information technologies: When will they make it into physicians’ black bags. Medscape Gen. Med. 6, 4 (2004), 2.
7. K. Baicker and J. Skinner. 2010. Health care spending growth and the future of US tax rates. In Tax Policy and the Economy, Volume 25. University of Chicago Press, 39--67.
8. J. E. Bailey, J. Y. Wan, L. M. Mabry, S. H. Landy, R. A. Pope, T. M. Waters, and M. E. Frisse. 2013. Does health information exchange reduce unnecessary neuroimaging and improve quality of headache care in the emergency department? J. Gen. Int. Med. 28, 2 (2013), 176--183.
9. P. Banks and E. Galvez. 2012. E-prescribing adoption: A prescription for progress. 2012. Retrieved March 2016 from https://www.healthit.gov/buzz-blog/state-hie/eprescribing-adoption/.
10. I. Bardhan, S. Ayabakan, E. Zheng, and K. Kirksey. 2014. Value of health information sharing in reducing healthcare waste: An analysis of duplicate testing across hospitals. In Proceedings of the Thirty Fifth International Conference on Information Systems. Auckland.
11. I. Bardhan, K. Kirksey, J. h. Oh, and E. Zheng. 2011. A predictive model for readmission of patients with congestive heart failure: A multi-hospital perspective. In Proceedings of the 32nd International Conference on Information Systems 2011. 1--39.
12. D. W. Bates, L. L. Leape, D. J. Cullen, N. Laird, L. A. Petersen, J. M. Teich, E. Burdick, M. Hickey, S. Kleefield, and B. Shea. 1998. Effect of computerized physician order entry and a team intervention on prevention of serious medication errors. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 280, 15 (1998), 1311--1316.
13. K. Bekelis, M. J. McGirt, S. L. Parker, C. M. Holland, J. Davies, C. J. Devin, T. Atkins, J. Knightly, R. Groman, and I. Zyung. 2015. The present and future of quality measures and public reporting in neurosurgery. Neurosurg. Focus 39, 6 (2015), E3.
14. T. G. Bentley, R. M. Effros, K. Palar, and E. B. Keeler. 2008. Waste in the US health care system: A conceptual framework. Milbank Quart. 86, 4 (2008), 629--659.
15. D. M. Berwick and A. D. Hackbarth. 2012. Eliminating waste in US health care. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 307, 14 (2012), 1513--1516.
16. D. Blumenthal and M. Tavenner. 2010. The meaningful use regulation for electronic health records. New Engl. J. Med. 363, 6 (2010), 501--504.
17. P. Branger, A. van't Hooft, and H. Van Der Wouden. 1994. Coordinating shared care using electronic data interchange. Medinfo. 8 (1994), 1669--1669.
18. M. L. Brown, G. F. Riley, N. Schussler, and R. Etzioni. 2002. Estimating health care costs related to cancer treatment from SEER-Medicare data. Med. Care 40, 8 (2002), IV-104-IV--117.
19. M. B. Buntin, M. F. Burke, M. C. Hoaglin, and D. Blumenthal. 2011. The benefits of health information technology: A review of the recent literature shows predominantly positive results. Health Affairs 30, 3 (2011), 464--471.
20. M. J. B. Buntin, J. J. Escarce, D. Goldman, H. Kan, M. J. Laugesen, and P. Shekelle. 2004. Increased Medicare expenditures for physicians’ services: What are the causes? J Health Care Organiz Provis. Financ. 41, 1 (2004), 83--94.
21. C. W. Burt and E. Hing. 2005. Use of computerized clinical support systems in medical settings: United States, 2001--03. Adv. Data 353, 1--8.
22. K. R. Campbell. 2016. Fixing our EHR mess: What needs to be done. 2016. Retrieved October 2016 from http://www.kevinmd.com/blog/2016/09/fixing-ehr-mess-needs-done.html.
23. B. Chaudhry, J. Wang, S. Wu, M. Maglione, W. Mojica, E. Roth, S. C. Morton, and P. G. Shekelle. 2006. Systematic review: Impact of health information technology on quality, efficiency, and costs of medical care. Ann. Int. Med. 144, 10 (2006), 742--752.
24. M. E. Chernew, K. Baicker, and J. Hsu. 2010. The specter of financial armageddon—health care and federal debt in the United States. New Engl. J. Med. 362, 13 (2010), 1166--1168.
25. CMS. About CMS. 2016. Retrieved March 2016 from https://www.cms.gov/About-CMS/About-CMS.html.
26. F. D. Davis, R. P. Bagozzi, and P. R. Warshaw. 1989. User acceptance of computer technology: A comparison of two theoretical models. Manag. Sci. 35, 8 (1989), 982--1003.
27. K. Davis, C. Schoen, and K. Stremikis. 2010. Mirror, mirror on the wall: How the performance of the U.S. Health Care System Compares Internationally
28. DHHS. Better Health Channel. 2015. Retrieved March 2016 from https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/.
29. B. E. Dowd, T. Swenson, S. Parashuram, R. Coulam, and R. Kane. 2016. PQRS Participation, inappropriate utilization of health care services, and Medicare expenditures. Medical Care Research and Review 1 (2016), 106--123.
30. R. H. Fazio and M. P. Zanna. 1978. On the predictive validity of attitudes: The roles of direct experience and confidence1. J. Pers. 46, 2 (1978), 228--243.
31. R. H. Fazio, M. P. Zanna, and J. Cooper. 1978. Direct experience and attitude-behavior consistency: An information processing analysis. Pers. Soc. Psychol. Bull. 4, 1 (1978), 48--51.
32. E. W. Ford, N. Menachemi, and M. T. Phillips. 2006. Predicting the adoption of electronic health records by physicians: When will health care be paperless? J. Am. Med. Inf. Assoc. 13, 1 (2006), 106--112.
33. A. J. Forster, H. J. Murff, J. F. Peterson, T. K. Gandhi, and D. W. Bates. 2003. The incidence and severity of adverse events affecting patients after discharge from the hospital. Ann. Int. Med. 138, 3 (2003), 161--167.
34. J. F. Fries, C. E. Koop, C. E. Beadle, P. P. Cooper, M. J. England, R. F. Greaves, J. J. Sokolov, and D. Wright. 1993. Reducing health care costs by reducing the need and demand for medical services. New Engl. J. Med. 329, 5 (1993), 321--325.
35. A. M. Garber and J. Skinner. 2008. Is American health care uniquely inefficient? J. Econ. Perspect. 22, 4 (2008), 27--50.
36. A. Gelman. 2012. Multilevel (hierarchical) modeling: What it can and cannot do. Technometrics 48, 3 (2006), 432--435.
37. G. D. Goetz, A. J. Kuzel, L. B. Feng, J. P. DeShazo, and L. E. Love. 2012. EHRs in primary care practices: Benefits, challenges, and successful strategies. Am. J. Manag. Care 18, 2 (2012), e48--54.
38. HealthAffairs. 2015. Where Is HITECH's $35 Billion Dollar Investment Going? Retrieved from http://healthaffairs.org/blog/2015/03/04/where-is-hitechs-35-billion-dollar-investment-going/.
39. HealthcareITNews. 2015. Electronic Health Records. Retrieved October 2016 from http://www.healthcareitnews.com/news/senator-blasts-ehr-program.
40. HEALTHeLINK. 2016. Participating HEALTHeLINK Providers. Retrieved September 2014 from http://wnyhealthelink.com/.
41. H. R. Hetico and D. E. Marcinko. 2010. The Business of Medical Practice: Transformational Health 2.0 Skills for Doctors. Springer, Berlin.
42. R. Hillestad, J. Bigelow, A. Bower, F. Girosi, R. Meili, R. Scoville, and R. Taylor. 2005. Can electronic medical record systems transform health care? Potential health benefits, Savings, and costs. Health Affairs 24, 5 (2005), 1103--1117.
43. J. M. Holroyd-Leduc, D. Lorenzetti, S. E. Straus, L. Sykes, and H. Quan. 2011. The impact of the electronic medical record on structure, process, and outcomes within primary care: A systematic review of the evidence. J. Am. Med. Inf. Assoc. 18, 6 (2011), 732--737.
44. W. C. Hsiao, D. B. Yntema, P. Braun, D. Dunn, and C. Spencer. 1988. Measurement and analysis of intraservice work. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 260, 16 (1988), 2361--2370.
45. A. Jamal, K. McKenzie, and M. Clark. 2009. The impact of health information technology on the quality of medical and health care: a systematic review. Health Inf. Manag. J. 38, 3 (2009), 26--37.
46. D. C. Kaelber and D. W. Bates. 2007. Health information exchange and patient safety. J. Biomed. Informat. 40, 6 (2007), S40--S45.
47. M. C. Katapodi, K. A. Lee, N. C. Facione, and M. J. Dodd. 2004. Predictors of perceived breast cancer risk and the relation between perceived risk and breast cancer screening: A meta-analytic review. Prev. Med. 38, 4 (2004), 388--402.
48. L. T. Kohn, J. M. Corrigan, and M. S. Donaldson. 2000. To Err Is H uman: Building a Safer Health System. National Academies Press.
49. J. Kwok and B. Jones. 2005. Unnecessary repeat requesting of tests: an audit in a government hospital immunology laboratory. J. Clin. Pathol. 58, 5 (2005), 457--462.
50. E. J. Lammers, J. Adler-Milstein, and K. E. Kocher. 2014. Does health information exchange reduce redundant imaging? Evid. Emerg. Dep. Med. Care 52, 3 (2014), 227--234.
51. A. Lloyd. 2001. The extent of patients’ understanding of the risk of treatments. Qual. Health Care 10, suppl. 1 (2001), i14--i18.
52. C. H. Mason and W. D. Perreault Jr. 1991. Collinearity, power, and interpretation of multiple regression analysis. J. Market. Res. 268--280.
53. S. Maxwell and S. Zuckerman. 2007. Impact of resource-based practice expenses on the medicare physician volume. Health Care Financ. Rev. 29, 2 (2007), 65.
54. D. J. Mazur, D. H. Hickam, and M. D. Mazur. 1999. How patients’ preferences for risk information influence treatment choice in a case of high risk and high therapeutic uncertainty asymptomatic localized prostate cancer. Med. Dec. Making 19, 4 (1999), 394--398.
55. I. McDonald, J. Daly, V. Jelinek, F. Panetta, and J. Gutman. 1996. Opening pandora's box: The unpredictability of reassurance by a normal test result. Br. Med. J. 313, 7053 (1996), 329--332.
56. A. R. Miller and C. Tucker. 2009. Privacy protection and technology diffusion: The case of electronic medical records. Manag. Sci. 55, 7 (2009), 1077--1093.
57. S. Miyakis, G. Karamanof, M. Liontos, and T. D. Mountokalakis. 2006. Factors contributing to inappropriate ordering of tests in an academic medical department and the effect of an educational feedback strategy. Postgrad. Med. J. 82, 974 (2006), 823--829.
58. C. Z. Mooney, R. D. Duval, and R. Duval. 1993. Bootstrapping: A Nonparametric Approach to Statistical Inference. Sage, Thousans Oaks, CA.
59. J. A. Nelder and R. J. Baker. 1972. Generalized linear models. In Encyclopedia of Statistical Sciences.
60. J. Neter, W. Wasserman, and M. H. Kutner. 1989. Applied Regression Models. Irwin, Homewood, IL.
61. L. Nguyen, E. Bellucci, and L. T. Nguyen. 2014. Electronic health records implementation: an evaluation of information system impact and contingency factors. Int. J.Med. Inf. 83, 11 (2014), 779--796.
62. P. R. Orszag. 2008a. Evidence on the costs and benefits of health information technology. Testimony Before Congress.
63. P. R. Orszag. 2008b. The overuse, underuse, and misuse of health care. Statement Before the Committee on Finance, U.S. Senate.
64. J. W. Osborne. 2000. The advantages of hierarchical linear modeling. Practical Assessment and Research Evaluation 7, 1 (2000). Available from: http://PAREonline.net/getvn.asp?v=78n=1.
65. Z. Ozdemir, J. Barron, and S. Bandyopadhyay. 2011. An analysis of the adoption of digital health records under switching costs. Inf. Syst. Res. 22, 3 (2011), 491--503.
66. S. G. Pauker and J. P. Kassirer. 1975. Therapeutic decision making: a cost-benefit analysis. New Engl. J. Med. 293, 5 (1975), 229--234.
67. W. L. S. Peter, J. Liu, E. Weinhandl, and Q. Fan. 2008. A comparison of sevelamer and calcium-based phosphate binders on mortality, hospitalization, and morbidity in hemodialysis: A secondary analysis of the Dialysis Clinical Outcomes Revisited (DCOR) randomized trial using claims data. Am. J. Kidney Dis. 51, 3 (2008), 445--454.
68. R. Platt and A. Ommaya. 2005. A beneficial side effect of the Medicare drug benefit. New Engl. J. Med. 353, 26 (2005), 2742--2743.
69. L. Poissant, J. Pereira, R. Tamblyn, and Y. Kawasumi. 2005. The impact of electronic health records on time efficiency of physicians and nurses: A systematic review. J. Am. Med. Inf. Assoc. 12, 5 (2005), 505--516.
70. S. Raudenbush and A. S. Bryk. 1986. A hierarchical model for studying school effects. Sociol. Educ. 1--17.
71. W. A. Ray. 1997. Policy and program analysis using administrative databases. Ann. Int. Med. 127, 8 Part 2 (1997), 712--718.
72. S. K. Riegg. 2008. Causal inference and omitted variable bias in financial aid research: Assessing solutions. Rev. High. Educ. 31, 3 (2008), 329--354.
73. J. D. Sargan. 1958. The estimation of economic relationships using instrumental variables. Econometrica. 393--415.
74. P. Shekelle, S. C. Morton, and E. B. Keeler. 2006. Costs and benefits of health information technology. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality US (Evidence Reports/Technology Assessments). Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK37988/.
75. M. Sipkoff. 2010. HIEs are slow going but critical part of HIT. Manag. Care (Langhorne, PA) 19, 3 (2010), 30--34.
76. S. Sivell, G. Elwyn, C. L. Gaff, A. J. Clarke, R. Iredale, C. Shaw, J. Dundon, H. Thornton, and A. Edwards. 2008. How risk is perceived, constructed and interpreted by clients in clinical genetics, and the effects on decision making: Systematic review. J. Gen. Counsel. 17, 1 (2008), 30--63.
77. P. C. Smith, R. Araya-Guerra, C. Bublitz, B. Parnes, L. M. Dickinson, R. Van Vorst, J. M. Westfall, and W. D. Pace. 2005. Missing clinical information during primary care visits. J. Am. Med. Assoc. 293, 5 (2005), 565--571.
78. M. Tabriz, K. Riederer, J. Baran, and R. Khatib. 2004. Repeating blood cultures during hospital stay: Practice pattern at a teaching hospital and a proposal for guidelines. Clin. Microbiol. Infect. 10, 7 (2004), 624--627.
79. W. M. Tierney, C. J. McDondald, D. K. Martin, S. L. Hui, and M. P. Rogers. 1987. Computerized display of past test results: Effect on outpatient testing. Ann. Int. Med. 107, 4 (1987), 569--574.
80. UCLA. 2016. How can I bootstrap estimates in SAS? Retrieved from http://www.ats.ucla.edu/stat/sas/faq/bootstrap.htm.
81. D. L. Veenstra, J. A. Roth, L. P. Garrison, S. D. Ramsey, and W. Burke. 2010. A formal risk-benefit framework for genomic tests: Facilitating the appropriate translation of genomics into clinical practice. Genet. Med. 12, 11 (2010), 686--693.
82. V. Venkatesh and F. D. Davis. 2000. A theoretical extension of the technology acceptance model: Four longitudinal field studies. Manag. Sci. 46, 2 (2000), 186--204.
83. J. R. Vest, L. M. Kern, M. D. Silver, and R. Kaushal. 2015. The potential for community based health information exchange systems to reduce hospital readmissions. J. Am. Med. Inf. Assoc. 22, 2 (2015), 435--442.
84. J. E. Wennberg, E. S. Fisher, T. A. Stukel, and S. M. Sharp. 2004. Use of medicare claims data to monitor provider-specific performance among patients with severe chronic illness. Health Affairs. VAR5-VAR18.
85. J. Westgard, T. Groth, T. Aronsson, H. Falk, and C. De Verdier. 1977. Performance characteristics of rules for internal quality control: probabilities for false rejection and error detection. Clin. Chem. 23, 10 (1977), 1857--1867.
86. E. T. Wong. 1995. Improving laboratory testing: Can we get physicians to focus on outcome? Clin. Chem. 41, 8 (1995), 1241--1247.
87. J. M. Wooldridge. 2012. Instrumental variables estimation and two-stage least squares. J. M. Wooldridge (ed.). Introductory Econometrics (3rd ed.). 510--551.
88. N. Yaraghi. 2015a. The benefits of health information exchange platforms: Measuring the returns on a half a billion dollar investment. Brookings Institution.
89. N. Yaraghi. 2015b. An empirical analysis of the financial benefits of health information exchange in emergency departments. J. Am. Med. Inf. Assoc. 22, 6 (2015), 1169--1172.
90. N. Yaraghi, A. Y. Du, R. Sharman, R. D. Gopal, and R. Ramesh. 2013. Network effects in health information exchange growth. ACM Trans. Manag. Inf. Syst. 4, 1 (2013), 1.
91. N. Yaraghi, A. Y. Du, R. Sharman, R. D. Gopal, and R. Ramesh. 2014a. Health information exchange as a multisided platform: Adoption, usage, and practice involvement in service co-production. Inf. Syst. Res. 26, 1 (2014a), 1--18.
92. N. Yaraghi, A. Y. Du, R. Sharman, R. D. Gopal, R. Ramesh, R. Singh, and G. Singh. 2014b. Professional and geographical network effects on healthcare information exchange growth: Does proximity really matter? J. Am. Med. Inf. Assoc. 21, 4 (2014b), 671--678.
93. B. J. Zikmund-Fisher, M. P. Couper, E. Singer, C. A. Levin, F. J. Fowler, S. Ziniel, P. A. Ubel, and A. Fagerlin. 2010. The DECISIONS study: A nationwide survey of united states adults regarding 9 common medical decisions. Med. Dec. Making 30, 5 Suppl. (2010), 20S--34S.

Index Terms

• Information systems

  • Information systems applications