Nicoletta Tancred
ABSTRACT
Moral dilemmas are a staple of narratives in games. Allowing the player to choose and impact a game's story is an important part of enjoying an interactive narrative. Yet when it comes to how we design and test games with moral dilemmas, there is little written on the subject. From this premise, The Moral Gameplay Taxonomy has been developed. Developed through an examination of 23 games, the taxonomy consists of two dimensions, creating four quadrants, which represent the different types of choices (systemic and scripted) provided to the player, and the style of endings (branching and linear). As this is a preliminary study, further work needs to be undertaken to develop the taxonomy further. It will be a valuable tool for examining how the design of moral dilemmas can affect player perceived agency and enjoyment in games.
- Arkane Studios. 2012.Dishonoured {PC}. (9 October 2012). Bethesda Softworks, Maryland, USA.Google Scholar
- Arkane Studios. 2016.Dishonoured 2{PC}. (11 November 2016). Bethesda Softworks, Maryland, USA.Google Scholar
- Arkane Studios.2017. Prey {PC}. (5 May 2017). Bethesda Softworks, Maryland, USA.Google Scholar
- Bethesda Software.2008. Fallout 3{PC}. (28 October 2008). Bethesda Game Studio, Montreal, Canada,Google Scholar
- Bethesda Software. 2010.Fallout: New Vegas {PC}. (19 October 2010) Obsidian Entertainment, Irvine, US.Google Scholar
- Bethesda Softworks. 2011.Elders Scroll V: Skyrim {PC}. (11 November 2011) Montreal, Canada: Bethesda Game StudioGoogle Scholar
- Bethesda Software. 2015.Fallout 4{PC}. (10 November 2015). Bethesda Game Studio, Montreal, Canada,Google Scholar
- Big Blue Box Studios. 2004.Fable {Xbox}. (14 September 2004). Microsoft Games Studio, Redmond, Washington, USA.Google Scholar
- Bioware.2007. Mass Effect {PC}. (November 20, 2007). Microsoft Studios & Electronic Arts, Redwood, Washington, USAGoogle Scholar
- Bioware.2009. Dragon Age: Origins {PC}. (3 November 2009). Electronic Arts, Redwood City, California, USA.Google Scholar
- Bioware.2010. Mass Effect 2 {PC}. (26 January 2010) Electronic Arts, Redwood City, California, USA.Google Scholar
- Bioware.2011. Dragon Age 2 {PC}. (8 March 2011). Electronic Arts, Redwood City, California, USA.Google Scholar
- Bioware.2012. Mass Effect 3 {PC}. (6 March 2012). Electronic Arts, Redwood City, California, USA.Google Scholar
- Bioware. 2014. Dragon Age: Inquisition {PC}. (18 November 2014). Electronic Arts, Redwood City, USA.Google Scholar
- Bioware.2017. Mass Effect: Andromeda {PC}. (21 March 2017). Electronic Arts, Redwood City, USA. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Frank G. Bosman. (2017). There Is No Solution! Games and Culture, 1--17.Google Scholar
- Peter Christiansen. (2017). Designing ethical systems for videogames. Proceedings of the International Conference on the Foundations of Digital Games - FDG '17, 1--7. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Mia Consalvo, Thorsten Busch, & Carolyn Jong. (2016). Playing a Better Me: How Players Rehearse Their Ethos via Moral Choices. Games and Culture, 1--20.Google Scholar
- Matthew William Fendt, Brent Harrison, Stephen G. Ware, Rogelio Cardona-Rivera, & David L. Roberts. (2012). Achieving the illusion of agency. In D. Oyarzun, F. Peinado, R. Michael Young, A. Elizalde, & G. Méndez (Eds.), Interactive Storytelling (Vol. 7648 LNCS, pp. 114--125). San Sebastian, Spain: Springer. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Paul Formosa, Malcolm Ryan, & Dan Staines. (2016). Papers, Please and the systemic approach to engaging ethical expertise in videogames. Ethics and Information Technology, 18(3), 211--225. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Frictional Games (2015). Soma {PC} Frictional Games, Helsingborg, Sweden.Google Scholar
- Giant Sparrow (2017). What Remains of Edith Finch {PC}. Annapurna Interactive, Los Angeles, California, USA.Google Scholar
- Stefano Gualeni. (2014). Augmented ontologies or how to philosophize with a digital hammer. Philosophy and Technology, 27(2), 177--199.Google ScholarCross Ref
- D. Fox Harrell & Jichen. (2009). Agency play: Dimensions of agency for interactive narrative design. Proceedings of the AAAI 2009 Spring Symposium on Narrative Intelligence II. Menlo Park: AAAI Press, 44--52. Retrieved from http://www.aaai.org/Papers/Symposia/Spring/2009/SS-09-06/SS09-06-008.pdfGoogle Scholar
- Michael James Heron & Pauline Helen Belford. (2014). Do You Feel Like a Hero Yet? Externalized Morality in Video Games. Journal of Games Criticism, 1(2). Retrieved from https://static1.squarespace.com/static/51f9aac5e4b080ed4b441ba7/t/53b02ae2e4b0182daaf7f3c4/1404054242059/HeronBelford-1-2.pdfGoogle Scholar
- Barry Ip. (2011). Narrative structures in computer and video games: Part 1: Context, definitions, and initial findings. Games and Culture, 6(2), 103--134.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Irrational Games.2013. Bioshock: Infinite {PC}. (26 March 2013). 2K Games, California, USA.Google Scholar
- Christoph Klimmt& Tilo Hartmann. (2006). Effectance, self-efficacy, and the motivation to play video games. Playing Video Games: Motives, Responses, and Consequences, (December), 153--168.Google Scholar
- Christoph Klimmt, Tilo Hartmann & Andreas Frey. (2007). Effectance and Control as Determinants of Video Game Enjoyment. CyberPsychology & Behavior, 10(6), 845--848.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Konami Computers & Entertainment Tokyo (2001), Silent Hill 2 {PC}. Konami, Tokyo, Japan:Google Scholar
- Mary Kuntz. (1993). The Prodikean "Choice of Herakles" a Reshaping of Myth. The Classical Journal, 89(2), 163--181. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/3297664Google Scholar
- Michael Mateas & Andrew Stern. (2005). Build It to Understand It: Ludology Meets Narratology in Game Design Space. DiGRA Conference Vancouver BC, 2, 16--20.Google Scholar
- Michael Mateas & Andrew Stern. (2005). Structuring content in the Façade interactive drama architecture. Proceedings of the First Artificial Intelligence and Interactive Digital Entertainment Conference, June 1-5, 2005, Marina Del Rey, California, USA, 3, 93--98. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Christopher Moser & Xiaowen Feng. (2014). Narrative Control and Player Experience in Role Playing Games: Decision Points and Branching Narrative Feedback. Human and Computer Interaction Application and Services, 8512(2), 622--633.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Janet H. Murray. (2017). Hamlet on The Holodeck: The Future of Narrative in Cyberspace (Updated Ed). Cambridge Massachusetts: MIT Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Jeff Nay, & Jose P Zagal (2017). Meaning Without Consequence: Virtue Ethics and Inconsequential Choices in Games. Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on the Foundations of Digital Games, 1--8. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Obsidian Entertainment. 2016.Tyranny {PC}. (10 November 2016). Paradox Interactive, Stockholm, Sweden.Google Scholar
- Oddworld Inhabitants/Digital Dialect.1997. Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee {PC}. (19 September 1997). GT Interactive, New York City, US.Google Scholar
- PIgeoNation Inc & Mediatonic.2011. Hatoful Boyfriend {PC}. (31 July 2011). (MIST {PSI} PRESS/Devolver Digital, Japan.Google Scholar
- Andrew K. Przybylski, C. Scott Rigby, & Richard M. Ryan. (2010). A Motivational Model of Video Game Engagement. Review of General Psychology, 14(2), 154--166.Google ScholarCross Ref
- Mark O. Riedl & R. Micheal Young. (2006). from linear story generation to branching story graphs. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, 26(3), 23--31. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Rockstar North.2008. Grand Theft Auto 4 {Xbox 360}. (29 April 2008). Rockstar Games, New York, USA.Google Scholar
- Sercan ?engün. (2013). Silent Hill 2 and the Curious Case of Invisible Agency. In D. Hutchison, T. Kanade, J. Kittler, & J. M. Kleinberg (Eds.), Interactive Storytelling (Vol. 6, pp. 180--185). Istanbul: Springer. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Miguel Sicart. (2005). The Ethics of Computer Game Design. Architecture. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Miguel Sicart. (2009). The Banality of Simulated Evil: Designing Ethical Gameplay. Google ScholarDigital Library
- Miguel Sicart. (2013). Beyond Choices: The Design of Ethical Gameplay (1st Ed.). Cambridge: MIT Press. Retrieved from http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.ezp01.library.qut.edu.au/xpl/bkabstractplus.jsp?bkn=6642240#toc Google ScholarDigital Library
- Miguel Sicart. (2013a). Moral Dilemmas in Computer Games. MIT, 29(3), 28--37.Google Scholar
- Supermassive Games. 2015. Until Dawn {PS4} (26 August 2015) Sony Computer Entertainment, Tokyo, Japan.Google Scholar
- Dan Staines, Paul Formosa, & Malcolm Ryan. (2017). Morality Play: A Model for Developing Games of Moral Expertise. Computer Graphics World, 24(3), 32.Google Scholar
- Jamey Stevenson (2010). A Framework for Classification and Criticism of Ethical Games. In K. Schrier & D. Gibson (Eds.), Designing Games for Ethics?: Models, Techniques and Frameworks (1st ed., pp. 36--55). Hershey, NJ: IGI Global.Google Scholar
- Telltale Games. 2012. The Walking Dead Season 1 {PC} (24 April 2012) Telltale Games, California, USA.Google Scholar
- Telltale Games. 2014. The Wolf amongst Us {PC}. (11 October 2013). Telltale Games, California, USA.Google Scholar
- Telltale Games. 2014. The Walking Dead Season 2 {PC}. (17 December 2013). Telltale Games, California, USA.Google Scholar
- Toby Fox. 2015. Undertales {PC}. (15 September 2015). Toby Fox, Boston, Massachusetts, USAGoogle Scholar
- Troika Games.2004. Vampire: The Masquerade: Bloodlines {PC}. (16 November 2004). Activision, Santa Monica, USA.Google Scholar
- Quantic Dream. 2005. Fahrenheit: Indigo Prophecy {PC}. (16 September 2005). Atari IncorporatedGoogle Scholar
- Quantic Dream. 2018. Detroit: Become Human {PS4}. (25 May 2018). Sony Interactive Entertainment, San Mateo, California, USA.Google Scholar
- José P. Zagal. (2009). Ethically Notable Videogames: Moral Dilemmas and Gameplay. Proceedings of DiGRA 2009, 9. Retrieved from http://www.digra.org/digital-library/publications/ethically-notable-videogames-moral-dilemmas-and-gameplay/Google Scholar
- 2K Boston & 2K Australia.2007. Bioshock {PC}. (21 August 2007). 2K Games, California, USA.Google Scholar
- 2K Marin.2010. Bioshock 2{PC}. (9 February 2010). 2K Games, California, USA.Google Scholar
- 3909 LLC.2014. Papers, Please {PC}. (8 August 2013). 3909 LLC.Google Scholar
Index Terms
- Player Choices, Game Endings and the Design of Moral Dilemmas in Games
Recommendations
“I Don’t Want To Shoot The Android”: Players Translate Real-Life Moral Intuitions to In-Game Decisions in Detroit: Become Human
CHI '22: Proceedings of the 2022 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing SystemsIn interactive story games, players make decisions that advance and modify the unfolding story. In many cases, these decisions have a moral component. Examining decision-making in these games illuminates whether players mobilize their real-life morality ...
How Game Ecology Drives Player Choices in Strategy Video Games: An Environmental Determinism Perspective
BackgroundRecent years have witnessed increasing attention on the study of game ecology, the virtual environments, and underlying mechanics within games. Yet, these studies often focus on the active role that players have in changing game ecology, ...
The Ethical Colonizer? Grand Strategy Games, Colonization, and New Ways of Engaging Moral Choices
Interactive StorytellingAbstractThis work explores the relationship of “4x” games rules, the historical narratives they offer, and player choice. Such games offer an ability for players to alter the accepted form and format of history by playing through alternate scenarios based ...
Comments